Newly reported filings show Clio refusing to restart a 2017 case law feed for ROSS, which says its contract runs to 2029.
A legal research company that shut down in 2021 now says it is coming back, and it wants its case law supply restored. The company that owns that supply says no. The dispute surfaced this week when [LawSites reported]( https://www.lawnext.com/2026/11/as-ross-seeks-to-come-back-from-the-dead-clio-sues-to-keep-its-case-law-out-of-reach.html) on the emails and letters attached to a lawsuit Clio filed against ROSS Intelligence.
The suit itself is not new. Clio filed it October 22 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, and the [complaint]( https://www.lawnext.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/E.D.-Va.-26-cv-03537-dckt-000001_000-filed-2026-10-22.pdf) asks for a declaratory judgment that Clio does not have to restart ROSS’s updates. The [Justia docket]( https://dockets.justia.com/docket/virginia/vaedce/1:2026cv03537/608901) lists Judge Rossie D. Alston Jr. What is new is what the attached correspondence shows about how the two sides got there.
What the Filings Show
In 2017, ROSS licensed a case law database from Casemaker, whose data Clio now owns through its purchase of the combined Casemaker, Fastcase and vLex business. LawSites reports that ROSS paid $900,000 for the database and agreed to pay $50,000 a year, in quarterly installments, for updates as courts issued new decisions. Clio’s complaint says ROSS stopped making those payments in mid-2020. ROSS announced in December 2020 that it would shut down, and its access to the feed ended January 31, 2021.
On June 18, 2026, ROSS cofounder Andrew Arruda emailed Clio CEO Jack Newton. LawSites quotes him writing that “we’re in the process of restarting ROSS operations and want to resume our agreement.” He asked how much ROSS owed and what updates would cost going forward.
Four months of emails and lawyers’ letters followed. Clio declined to reactivate the feed. ROSS says the contract renewed automatically and runs through September 27, 2029. Clio says ROSS’s years of nonpayment excused it from further delivery. The complaint says Clio is not trying to block a relaunch or to challenge ROSS’s rights to the data it already received. It asks only for a ruling that Clio need not deliver cases decided since.
Paused or Over
The two sides read the same emails differently. Nine days after the shutdown, a Fastcase executive asked ROSS whether to keep sending invoices, writing that “our expectation is that we should pause invoicing,” according to LawSites. Arruda replied that “things are on pause for now.” ROSS says that exchange was a mutual pause of the whole agreement. Clio says it covered invoicing only, and that the contract can be changed only by a signed writing.
ROSS also says Clio never gave the notice and 30 days to cure that the contract requires. When Newton sent a notice of breach on September 24, Arruda answered the same day that ROSS “hereby tenders cure” and asked for an invoice. Clio has declined to provide one. The sides also disagree on what ROSS paid: ROSS points to nine wire transfers in 2019 and 2020, and Clio says those covered a separate 2018 license for statutes and regulations. A court will have to sort out which reading holds, and ROSS has not yet responded to the complaint.
Why Clio Says No
The correspondence also shows Clio’s stated reason. In a June 25 email quoted by LawSites, Newton told Arruda:
“We are not doing these kinds of data licensing deals on a go-forward
basis.”
ROSS’s lawyer, Joshua Hafenbrack of Cozen O’Connor, characterized that position in an October 5 letter, according to LawSites:
“Clio is using the Fastcase data to create a data moat around Clio’s own
vertically integrated AI platform.”
That is ROSS’s characterization, not Clio’s. Clio’s lawyer, Jess Krannich of Wilson Sonsini, wrote that “ROSS should make other arrangements for its data needs.” LawSites notes that Newton recently called data “the only durable moat” in an interview.
The same theme runs through the other Clio data dispute. Alexi filed antitrust counterclaims against Clio in January, after Fastcase sued it over its use of licensed case law, and Hafenbrack’s letter echoes that argument. [LawSites reported]( https://www.lawnext.com/2026/11/mediation-fails-to-resolve-fastcase-alexi-lawsuit-over-alleged-data-misuse.html) on November 17 that a November 10 mediation did not settle that case.
Questions to Ask Your Research Vendor
You do not need a side in either lawsuit to take something from them. Legal research tools run on case law that someone has to license, and that someone can also be a competitor.
For GCs, legal ops teams and partners buying or renewing research tools, the practical questions are plain ones. Where does the vendor’s case law come from, and does it hold the rights itself or license them from a third party? If it is licensed, how long does the license run and who can end it? What happens to your searches, saved work and integrations if that license lapses or the supplier stops selling? Ask for those answers in the contract, not on a sales call.
None of this means any vendor’s supply is at risk. It means the answer is worth having before you depend on the tool.
What to Watch
ROSS has not answered the complaint, and the filings give no details on its relaunch, including what a relaunch would look like or when it would happen. Arruda told LawSites: “We are confident the contract is clear on ROSS’s data rights and we will pursue all legal remedies. We remain excited about the future of AI in legal.”
Watch for ROSS’s response in Virginia and for any announcement of what ROSS is relaunching. Separately, LawSites reports that the Third Circuit ruled against ROSS on September 29, holding its use of Westlaw headnotes to train its AI was not fair use, and that ROSS petitioned on November 3 for rehearing by the full court. One more detail comes only from ROSS’s side: its lawyer’s letter says Newton was a member of ROSS’s board at the time of the 2021 pause. Clio’s complaint does not mention it, and we have not seen it confirmed elsewhere.
[image: Legal Tech Circle] <https://legaltechcircle.com/> Quinn Ashby The Circle Desk, Legal Tech Circle quinn@legaltechcircle.com | legaltechcircle.com Legal Tech Funding Tracker <https://legaltechcircle.com/market-signals/funding-tracker/?utm_source=email&utm_medium=signature&utm_campaign=quinn>: every round since 2012
