Davis Polk is the latest firm to put AI in the C-suite. What five chief AI officer hires say about who now owns the legal tech buying decision.
For most of the last decade, a legal tech sale at a large firm meant convincing a CIO, a knowledge management director, an innovation lead and a few influential partners, often separately. That room is getting a new chair. On November 9, LawSites reported that Nikki Shaver, cofounder and CEO of Legaltech Hub, is leaving the company on December 1 to join Davis Polk & Wardwell as chief AI and knowledge officer. Jeroen Plink, the company’s COO and a major investor, becomes CEO.
Shaver spent five years running one of the best known legal tech directories and analyst shops. Her move inside a firm is a strong signal that the people who evaluate legal AI for a living are now being hired to own the decision.
“Having spent five years driving change from outside of a firm, I’m excited to work again on the inside,” Shaver wrote in her farewell note on Legaltech Hub.
Three Ways Firms Are Filling the Role
The public announcements from the last year show at least three hiring patterns, and each one changes who a vendor is really selling to.
The first is promoting a technologist from inside. Arnold & Porter named Roger Maeda its first chief artificial intelligence officer on July 13. He had been the firm’s Director of Enterprise Applications and Application Development, and the firm says he will lead a dedicated AI team that partners with innovation, technology and business services leaders to build, test and deploy AI tools.
“The firm created this role because AI is reshaping how we deliver legal services, and that shift demands dedicated leadership at the highest level,” said Ellen Kaye Fleishhacker, Global Co-Chair of Arnold & Porter.
The second is hiring a practicing lawyer who has run innovation. Littler appointed Stephanie Goutos as its first chief AI officer on April 8. She came from Gunderson Dettmer, where she was Head of Employment Law Practice Innovation, and brings nearly 15 years of employment law experience. Littler says she will work with its Chief Digital Innovation Officer, Carlos Gonzalez, and “align AI and technology investments with Littler’s strategic priorities.” That puts investment decisions inside the job description.
The third pattern folds AI into knowledge management. Pillsbury hired Oz Benamram as chief AI officer in July. He previously built innovation functions at Simpson Thacher, White & Case and Morrison & Foerster, and at Pillsbury he leads AI strategy, governance and enablement infrastructure plus the firm’s data science and knowledge management functions. Davis Polk’s title, chief AI and knowledge officer, follows the same logic. So did Morgan Lewis, which retitled Colleen Nihill as chief AI and knowledge officer in May 2025, according to an American Lawyer report republished by Skadden.
The Buyer With a VC Mindset
The most candid public description of how this role buys came from Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer. In a March interview with Business Insider, global chief AI officer Ilona Logvinova said the role reports directly to chief executive Justin D’Agostino, and that she runs a team of “forward-deployed legal engineers” who sit with lawyers, watch how work gets done and build AI into those routines.
“I very much take a VC mindset,” Logvinova said, “because I don’t see it as buying SaaS off the shelf.”
She told the outlet she spends much of her time meeting founders and tracking product road maps. The firm had rolled Legora out firmwide but declined to name its other vendors. That reticence is worth noting. A chief AI officer who treats vendors as a portfolio will keep options open, test competing tools and avoid public commitments that make switching harder.
What Changes for Vendors and Internal Champions
For vendors, one accountable owner can shorten a sale. It also raises the bar. A chief AI officer with a governance mandate will ask about data retention, model training, permissions, audit logs and how outputs are verified before they ask about features. When the role also owns knowledge management, as at Pillsbury, Davis Polk and Morgan Lewis, the questions extend to how a tool uses the firm’s precedents and work product and who controls that content afterward.
For lawyers and legal ops staff pushing a new tool from inside, the route has changed too. The pitch now goes to someone measured on adoption and risk across the whole firm, not just one practice group’s enthusiasm. That person still needs partners on side, which is the problem we covered in Getting Partner Buy-In for New Legal Tech Tools. A title does not settle a partnership’s politics. It gives someone the job of working through them.
There are limits to what the announcements tell us. None of these firms has published the role’s budget authority, headcount or how it splits decisions with the CIO and practice leaders. Titles also vary. Skadden, for example, hired a chief digital and information officer rather than a chief AI officer, with AI deployment inside a broader technology remit.
Common Questions
Which firms have named a chief AI officer?
Public announcements cover Arnold & Porter, Littler, Pillsbury and HSF Kramer, with Davis Polk adding a chief AI and knowledge officer from December 1. Morgan Lewis uses the combined chief AI and knowledge officer title.
Do these roles control the legal tech budget?
Not always, and not publicly. Littler’s release ties its role to aligning AI and technology investments, but none of the firms has disclosed the role’s spending authority.
Why combine AI with knowledge management?
Legal AI tools are only as useful as the firm content they can reach. Pairing the two puts tool selection and the firm’s precedents, data and work product under one owner.
What should a vendor bring to a chief AI officer meeting?
Clear answers on data handling, permissions and verification, a named use case with a practice sponsor, and a plan for adoption after the pilot.
Verdict
Real. Large firms are giving legal AI a senior owner, drawn from IT, from practice innovation and from knowledge management. Expect fewer side-door pilots and more portfolio-style buying, with governance questions arriving before the demo.
*QUINN ASHBY*Staff Writer, Legal Tech Circle
e. quinn@lionfiregroup.co w. www.lionfiregroup.co
In this story
See every round in the Funding Tracker